Skip to content
🏆 Honored with the Consumers Choice Award 2026!
Cabot Creamery

Cabot Creamery

www.cabotcheese.coop
What is your customer experience with Cabot Creamery?

Cabot Creamery Overview

The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

Based on reviews, created with AI
Rating Distribution

Cabot Creamery reviews show a 4.1 star rating from 14 customers with 82% would likely recommend and a 79% positive vs 21% unfavorable distribution.

Key Takeaways for Future Customers

  • Expect generally good value and quality and check expiration before use.
  • Customer service can respond by callback or email, and refunds are the common requested remedy.
  • Price level is low and many praise yogurt and cheese varieties.

Negative Feedback / Risk Areas

  • Cabot Creamery customer complaints often cite moldy products appearing before expiration.
  • Many report difficulty reaching support by phone and inconsistent packaging (foil or seal issues).
  • Occasional delivery or order fulfillment problems and product quality inconsistencies are reported.

Positive Feedback

Customers note good quality, lactose-free labeling, fair pricing, prompt callbacks in some cases, helpful explanations, coupons offered, and strong praise for certain yogurts and cheeses.

View full overview ›

Media from reviews

Cabot Creamery - Today is February 2, 2026! I have some cabbage Vermont seriously sharp...
Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheeseCabot Creamery - I didn't even get to eat a piece of my pepper jack go to have a piece...Cabot Creamery - I didn't even get to eat a piece of my pepper jack go to have... - Image 2Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheddar cheeseCabot Creamery - Moldy cheddar cheese - Image 2Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheddar cheese - Image 3
View all media ›

Turn one complaint into a collective action

PC collective complaint

A Collective Complaint helps you unite consumers dealing with the same issue, such as wrong charges, unexpected fees, damaged items, or misleading promises. It goes beyond a single review by growing stronger with every signature, making it harder to ignore. Once you reach 20 supporters, we’ll send it to the company to encourage a response.

Start Collective Complaint
Show reviews that mention
cheese cheddar cheddar cheese date sharp cheddar products cabot expiration date coupons expiration
Filter review
Sort by
Alexza Xfx

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Kissimmee, Florida

I can’t rate this company, I don’t know you. Your product are Great but the customer service is deplorable.

AI Highlights
  • - Only receives emails and does not engage with them.
  • - Requesting a resolution about the lifespan of a product.

Im only receiving emails, I dont do emails! That is all the response that I have to give at this current moment.

Well, I dont know.

I just encourage. You are responding to my request for a resolution to the situation that I am currently undergoing due to your lifespan of one of your products.

View full review
Alexza Xfx

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Kissimmee, Florida

Today is February 2, 2026! I have some cabbage Vermont seriously sharp cheddar cheese expiration date, 1028 ****. My cheese is molded it and it’s the second time that this has happened to me.What do I

Cabot Creamery - Today is February 2, 2026! I have some cabbage Vermont seriously sharp...

My cheese molded before its expiration date matter of fact its eight months until the expiration date. So what do I do?

User's recommendation: Checking expiration date will not solve a problem. But I don’t have money to waste.

View full review
Kathy R Dhr

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Niagara Falls, New York

Moldy cheese

AI Highlights
  • - Bought cheese for a Thanksgiving recipe and found mold after opening the package.
  • - Extremely disappointed with the product.
Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheese

Purchased cheese for recipe for Thanksgiving recipe tomorrow, I opened the package and the cheese was moldy. All information son package below. Extremely disappointed.

Kathy Rotella

70 Carrollwood Ct

Youngstown, ny 14174

716 425 ****

Loss:
$4
Cons:
  • Moldy

Preferred solution: Full refund

View full review
Caty Ayd
map-marker Charleston, Illinois

Completely satisfied

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - The company explained why the liquid was in the packaging; I understand the reason.
  • - They offered coupons.
  • - The call was pleasant and informative.

The company made me aware of why the liquid was in the packaging in my 65 years is the first time that this has happened I totally understand why it was there. The company offered to send coupons. I was educated they were very pleasant on the phone call couldnt have asked for anything better.

View full review
Joanne B Jxn

Coupons and question in paperback cheese

AI Highlights
  • - I love the products.
  • - Pepper jack seems less rich; Alpine crystals no longer crunchy; last bars vary; I probably buy 6–10 bars weekly and ask about coupons.

I received a voicemail waiting for a call back. I love your products!

The thing that I noticed is that the pepper jack cheese is not as rich and luscious. It seems like it's made with low-fat milk instead. The last two or three bars have been different, and the alpine cheese—those little crystal things. It was like a little crunchy crystal; it's not like that anymore, which I did like.

I know people probably complain that it was weirdly crunchy.

Anyway, my address is Joanne Broberg, 305 Grogan Rd., Barre, MA 01005. If you do have any coupons, like I said, I probably buy 6 to 10 bars of your cheese a week!

View full review
Nysa Han

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

I didn't even get to eat a piece of my pepper jack go to have a piece and it was completely molded and the date for expiration isn't till August 15th 2025

Cabot Creamery - I didn't even get to eat a piece of my pepper jack go to have a piece...
Cabot Creamery - I didn't even get to eat a piece of my pepper jack go to have... - Image 2

Feeling wasted my money and I've been buying the same shoes forever it never had experience this before but when you're on a budget money-wise it's very upsetting.

View full review
Kurt D Ppn

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Montpelier, Vermont

Concerns of quality of one of your cheese products

Cabot Creamery - Concerns of quality of one of your cheese products

The Cabot NY Xtra Sharp cheese that I bought several packages of tasted very bland and had moisture in the package. I have been a big fan of your cheese products up until recently.

Loss:
$18
Pros:
  • Love the ny xtra sharp cheese
Cons:
  • Recently taste is way off does not taste the same

Preferred solution: Full refund

User's recommendation: Continue buying cabot cheese products from Costco

View full review
Katherine R Gks

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

This is the BEST yougart I have ever eaten in my life. I wanted to let them know.

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Triple-cream vanilla bean Greek yogurt is the preferred brand.
  • - Nothing else compares in taste.
  • - It's fattening but valued for its nutrition.

They have a triple.cream vanilla bean greek yogurt. As long as I live, I never want to eat another brand of yogurt.

In fact after eating this product. Yougart will never be the same for me again because nothing else compares to how good this yogurt is. It has to be the triple. Cream vanilla bean.

It is fattening, but I don't mind. That's good old nutritional value.

Without anything added That's considered poison like almost everything we find on shelves these days. AMAZING PRODUCT PLEASE DON'T EVER STOP PRODUCING IT.

User's recommendation: Triple.Cream Vanilla Bean Greek Yougart

View full review
Collyn Gqh

Moldy cheddar cheese

Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheddar cheese
Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheddar cheese - Image 2
Cabot Creamery - Moldy cheddar cheese - Image 3

Bought a 8 oz. Cabot Vermont cheddar cheese, it is moldy unopened ex.

Date 8/17/25. Would like replacement.

View full review
Keria Ksb

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Wanted to know if white on edges was ok to consume

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Bought 8oz Cabot Seriously Sharp cheese.
  • - Edges were white.
  • - Cabot rep called within an hour to explain the white.
  • - The white is normal for aging cheddar.

Bought 8oz packages of cabot seriously sharp cheese

On the edges was white.

Cabot called me back within the hour and rep explained what the white was.

She eased my mind of what white was. Said normal when cheddars age.

Gave her date, code and time printed on package.

Very satisfied with Cabots excellent customer service.

User's recommendation: Very reputable company. They will call back even if you leave a message.

View full review
Stacey M Hbs

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Moldy cheese

AI Highlights
  • - I tried calling Cabot several times and got voicemail.
  • - Unopened cracker cut cheddar cheese had a November expiration and grew mold; I threw it out.

I tried to call Cabot several times and I kept getting a leave a message. I bought a pack of cracker cut cheddar cheese and it had an expiration date in November.

It was unopened and was growing mold.

I threw it out since I could not reach anyone on the phone. I love Cabot cheese and will continue to buy it but I wish they had a reachable phone number

Loss:
$4
Pros:
  • Always says lactose free
Cons:
  • No e

Preferred solution: Full refund

View full review
1 comment
Guest

Please accept our sincere apologies for the unsatisfactory purchase. I can be reached directly at 802-431-**** or info@***.com.

We gladly offer you coupons to enjoy as a token of our appreciation for your continued support.

If you would like to accept our offer, please reply with a mailing address. Sincerely, Michael

Anonymous
map-marker Delray Beach, Florida

Gouda Cheese is way oversalted

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - I love Gouda cheese.
  • - The salt content is very high lately.
  • - Please cut the salt back because it is unhealthy and ruins the taste.

I love the Gouda cheese but as of late the salt content is through the roof. Please have this cut way back since salt content like this is very unhealthy and the salt ruins the great taste.

J.Gordon

View full review
Anonymous
map-marker Middletown, New York

Extreme sharp cheddar is not crumbly, not sharp at all, and taste like its made from vegetable oil

extreme sharp cheddar is not crumbly, not sharp at all, and taste like its made from vegetable oil, age it

View full review
Aniston Xif

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Searching for Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp cheddar cheese Popcorn

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

Requested where product can be purchased. No response.

This response site is horrible.

This is the best cheese popcorn my wife and I have ever tasted. ',,,

View full review
Bowman Zge

Prompt and helpful.

They answered my questions professionally, and will be sending coupons for me to replace the product in question.

View full review
Aniston Xif

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Searching for Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp cheddar cheese Popcorn

Updated by user Mar 11, 2025

Unable to contact anyone to answer the question I had as to where to purchase the product.

Original review Mar 10, 2025

Still havent received an answer as to where the Cabot Creamery extra sharp chedder popcorn can be purchased.

User's recommendation: Don’t call of send email they don’t respond.

View full review

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article